← Notebook
Behind the app

Why we don't estimate feed volume.

In short. Little Bean does not guess how much milk your baby drank. Bottles and pumping sessions get the amount you type. A breastfeed gets the side and the time, and no millilitre figure, because nobody can see it. To tell whether a breastfed baby is getting enough, the NHS points to wet and dirty diapers and steady weight gain.

How much milk is enough? It is one of the first questions new parents ask, and one of the hardest to answer with a number. A baby tracker could put a number on every feed. We decided Little Bean would not, and this note explains why.

What the guidance actually says

For formula, the NHS gives a rough daily range: after the first week, most babies need around 150 to 200 ml per kilo of body weight a day, until about six months. The same page adds that this varies from baby to baby, and that babies should be fed when they show they want it, not to a fixed amount.

For breastfeeding there is no amount to read. Nobody can see how much milk went in, and the NHS does not ask you to work it out. It describes signs instead. Your baby gains weight steadily after the first three or four days. From the fourth day there are at least two soft, yellow poos a day for the first few weeks. From day five there are at least six heavy, wet diapers every 24 hours.

So the guidance itself works with ranges and signs, not with a precise volume per feed. That is the first reason a tracker should be careful with a millilitre figure.

A guess that looks like data

A breastfeed in your log has a time, a side and a duration. Fifteen minutes on one side can be a full feed or a sleepy snack, and the log cannot tell the difference. Any millilitre figure calculated from that would be invented.

The trouble is where that figure would appear. It would sit on the same screen as the bottle you measured and the weight the health visitor wrote down, in the same font, and it would read as just as real. A low estimate can worry a parent whose baby is doing fine. A high one can reassure a parent who should be making a call. A number nobody measured should not be treated as a health number.

Estimated feed volumes have a quieter cost too. Once an app shows a total for the day, parents start feeding toward the total. The guidance points the other way: feed the baby in front of you, and watch the diapers and the weight.

What Little Bean does instead

Every amount in your log is one somebody entered. A bottle is logged with what was in it and how much, and a pumping session with the amount expressed. Those amounts add up to a daily bottle total and, over a longer range, a per day average, so you can see how the bottles are going.

A breastfeed is logged by side and duration, with a timer or after the fact. It counts as a feed in your totals and in the rhythm of the day. It never gets a volume attached, not on the chart and not in the detail sheet.

Diapers and weights sit on the same timeline, and for a breastfed baby those are the numbers the guidance actually uses. Two taps for a wet diaper is the closest thing to a feed volume that breastfeeding offers.

Where we do estimate

Little Bean's refusal to guess breastfeed volume is not a rule against every estimate. Little Bean estimates timing, because your log holds real times. The feed pill on the Today screen shows when the next feed usually comes, and it says nothing at all until your last week holds at least four daytime gaps between feeds across two days. It uses the middle value of those gaps, so one odd afternoon does not move it, and it stays quiet at night. The next nap estimate is built on the same principle.

The difference is what the estimate stands on. A feed time is something you recorded. A millilitre figure for a breastfeed is something nobody recorded, and no amount of history changes that.

If you are handing the day to someone else, the bottle amounts are the part they will need most. The note on going back to work covers which lines to keep when the feeds move from breast to bottle. Feeds, sleep, diapers and growth are in every plan, and the plans page has the detail.

Log what you can see, and let the diapers and the weight answer what you cannot. That is a calmer way to know your baby is getting enough.

Every baby feeds differently. If you are worried your baby is not getting enough milk, if there are fewer wet or dirty diapers than usual, if your baby is not gaining weight or seems unusually sleepy, contact your midwife, health visitor or doctor. A log helps you see the pattern; a professional is the person to read it with you. Nothing here is medical advice.

Sources

Editorial policy: AI-assisted. Drafted by Erwin with AI assistance, then reviewed, edited and approved by Erwin. Health facts are checked against primary sources such as the NHS, AAP and WHO. How we write · About Erwin.

One short note, once a month.

A single practical piece for the stage your baby is in. No spam, unsubscribe in one tap.